665b1f8d9971a

665b1f8d9a41d
1 Guest is here.
 

Topic: SSR The System Shock demo is OUT! Read 19802 times  

« Last Edit: 29. June 2016, 22:02:41 by Kolya »

665b1f8d9b06fNameless Voice

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9b0cd
It's really short - basically just what was shown in the demo.

Looks pretty cool overall, though of course I still hate the completely changed Rebecca storyline, and how even the "Welcome back to Citadel Station" message is cropped short.

I like that you can still choose to not pick up the bio monitor hardware so it doesn't clutter up your screen.


Apologies to the people who complained about the pickup animations and ladders in the video - I thought they were being silly - but once I'm actually playing it, those both feel really awkward.  The pickup animation would be cool if it didn't lock you out from picking up any more objects and force you to move at a crawl until it finished.  A short animation is cool, but one that completely stops you from being able to play isn't.
As for ladders, they just feel really awkward and clunky.  You can't even jump into them to start climbing higher up.

I'm sure the animation of climbing into the medbed will get very old very fast, too.

It's also really strange that the inventory blurs out your entire view, but doesn't pause the game.
« Last Edit: 28. June 2016, 19:51:40 by Nameless Voice »
Acknowledged by: Kolya

665b1f8d9b257voodoo47

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9b2a4
runs on my Athlon64 X2/HD6850/6GB ram - barely. the demo is fine for what it is - confirming everything that has been said when analyzing the video. definitely could use less flashiness, and an UI overlay for the puzzles. ladders feel unintuitive and clunky. also crashed on me once. but yes, it was an interesting trip back, and I would play more if I could, despite the poor performance.

also yeah, leaning and invert mouse.
« Last Edit: 28. June 2016, 20:08:40 by voodoo47 »

665b1f8d9b354Schuler

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9b39d
And I'm still downloading. I'll just say, I hope it doesn't look too generic like in some of the images I've seen, like they got carried away with the 201X effects and forgot what made the 1992 (I think) textures striking.

665b1f8d9b451Nameless Voice

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9b49a
I just noticed that you can smash the lights.

The settings on the Sparq are really hard to see (and I only figured out you could change the setting because someone told me, the key (F) is not even listed in the keybindings.)
« Last Edit: 28. June 2016, 20:03:05 by Nameless Voice »

665b1f8d9b5efSchuler

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9b63c
Pausing a few minutes in for first impressions:

- Running a laptop (GT 840M), so bad performance - that's okay, I don't expect it from a demo.
+ Emphasising the cyber part of cyberpunk, like the pixellating display and the UI "coming online" as the hardware is installed, and the Hacker's hand and gloves being visible in equipping animations.
+ Existing.
+ Keeping the mouseover text labels. Can see storytelling potential there.
+ The environment, with the bodies and such feels great, however;
- I think, as I feared, that the lighting effects are a tad overdone, and would prefer a less shiny look for a horror game set on a utilitarian station, especially the spark effects in healing and charging. Maybe show the Hacker grabbing a charging cable? Really shiny storage room, for example.
- The oversized switch looks weird, would have preferred them scaled down to compensate for the much better resolution.
« Last Edit: 28. June 2016, 20:17:51 by Schuler »

665b1f8d9b94bvoodoo47

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9b99f
+ Existing.
well yes, I'll admit that after years of failed remake attempts, having something that can actually be played was rather nice.

665b1f8d9bc71JosiahJack

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9bcec
well yes, I'll admit that after years of failed remake attempts, having something that can actually be played was rather nice.
Ouch
Acknowledged by 4 members: Nameless Voice, Hikari, Learonys, Schuler

665b1f8d9bdafSchuler

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9bdfe
Even if I have hangups about this, I think I'll still pledge on Kickstarter when I have the money. I love SS1 too much not to.
Acknowledged by: icemann
Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9c023
I'm not sure if I'll be able to actually play or not, which normal people would go 'well save up for a year get a new computer.'

Something i cannot do. So I'm torn here given it's for something i won't be able to enjoy unless i put in for a soundtrack. However i'm probably going to back anyway because it exists and early access information.

665b1f8d9c0f9Schuler

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9c145
FWIW, the game looks decent at very low resolutions.

665b1f8d9c446ThiefsieFool

Re: The System Shock (Reboot) demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9c4af
I'm really not feeling the tiny interaction objects. What I would much prefer is:
- you can use the whole Surgical Bed to heal, not just a tiny button
- for keypads and puzzles you don't necessarily have to create an interface that "takes you out of the game" or whatever, just move the camera really close to the widget so that rightclicking the individual buttons is not so finnicky
Acknowledged by 2 members: Kolya, Learonys

665b1f8d9c74dSchuler

Re: The System Shock (Reboot) demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9c7a0
I'm really not feeling the tiny interaction objects. What I would much prefer is:
- you can use the whole Surgical Bed to heal, not just a tiny button
- for keypads and puzzles you don't necessarily have to create an interface that "takes you out of the game" or whatever, just move the camera really close to the widget so that rightclicking the individual buttons is not so finnicky

Same for both. What I was thinking of was a zoomed-in portion of the screen with a free mouse, but ours works better. Oh, and letting me use my numpad as an input for the keypads, like Deus Ex: HR would be nice.

665b1f8d9ca64Learonys

Re: The System Shock (Reboot) demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9cab1
Well, I played the demo and these are notable things worth mentioning:

- I broke the game by changing the FOV to the minimum. The screen basically got cropped and i could no longer press the apply button to put it back to normal. :(

- I decided to smash the screen of a computer to see what happens and a nice surface effect was shown! It might need some work because the shattered glass effect partially went over to the metal part of the computer but it's nice to see attention to detail is put in the game.

- I decided to examine the..... Cryogenic incubator?, and I just loved the text bars that popped up. Not a single, boring line of text, but different and personalised responses every time you clicked on it. I see good storyline potential, but i'm still sticking to my opinion that the efforts to portray the Hacker as a badass does not suit his surroundings a bit. The surrounding atmosphere needs a change if they want to make this work.

- The monsters in-game did not really scare me generally, but i did managed to get jumpscared once! I heard a serve-bot but did not see him, so I ignored him and went to the Energy charge station. It must have been perfect timing but at the exact moment I charged my energy, my character started screaming and i got pushed forward, on top of the charge station! I thought the charge station malfunctioned and was going to get me killed! ...Just to find out the Serve-bot that I heard chased me and pushed me forward.
You know, if you could make enemies do these kinds of things on purpose... The potential is unreal!

- I thought the Sparq beam had only two settings, until i pressed F once and my energy drain was a lot lower than expected! Further expection showed me there were not two, but four settings, but i simply wasn't able to see them. This should be made a bit more obvious. So i shot the Sparq beam at the lowest setting, and the beam was a lot less vibrant. I liked this, it wasn't as much as a fireworks show as the Polygon gameplay video showed, it just doesn't fit the weapon.

- I liked the look and the functionality of the grid puzzle! But at first it was a bit confusing to me which button was enabled and which one disabled, It seems like you can't turn these buttons on the grid puzzle off again, so I kept pressing the already turned on buttons in frustration because nothing happened. But off course this isn't going to be an issue the second time you do this.

665b1f8d9ccb9voodoo47

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9cd09
Ouch
what, are you aware of something fully playable (and public) at this moment?

665b1f8d9cf45Schuler

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9cf95
what, are you aware of something fully playable (and public) at this moment?

https://www.systemshock.org/index.php?topic=6977.0
Re: The System Shock (Reboot) demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9d40c
The demo is way too short and the game is in a very unfinished state, so it's hard to say if Night Dive has what it takes, but based solely on what's in the demo, I'd never in a million years back this game.

- My eyes are constantly assaulted by a shitton of different effects, none of which I can disable right now. Not only do I find excessive bloom, DOF, oversaturation, or other fullscreen effects hideous, they distract from the game and make it difficult to notice details. The overabundance of environmental effects and animated textures clutter up the screen and I have a hard time discerning decals from actual switches and items. I don't care about "spooky" smoke or flashy sparks. If I can't see what's happening in the game, then the art department messed up royally. Truly bizarre when you think about how much better SS1 and SS2 are in this regard while still perveying the feeling of being alone on a derelict space station infested by horrible things in the dark that want to kill you. Sometimes, less is more. I do like the general asthetic, but they're unfit for a game of this type at the moment.

- Movement and hit detection give me the sense of fighting sloths with a slingshot in a water tank filled with honey. The player is laughably slow (don't want to frighten the console audience?), enemies are even slower. Sometimes I miss the enemy when a swing should clearly connect, sometimes the zombies' attacks seem to cover an impossible range.

- Did I miss all of the hotkeys or is there really no way to quicly move an item from a container to the inventory, switch weapons, play the last email, that sort of thing? Feels clunky/finnicky and slow at the moment. Same goes for the in-game interfaces with the tiny buttons everywhere. Wasn't one of the main complaints about SS1 how its interface is so difficult to operate? Well, this one's worse.

- Performance is pretty bad fora game of this graphical quality, but sine my PC is ancient, I'll let it slide.

Bottom line: Demo failed to draw me into the game in any meaningful way, they should probably not have released it in this state. All of the major problems I noticed can definitely be fixed, but all in all, I currently don't see any reason why I should invest into this game when I already have the original and Citadel's on the way.
Re: The System Shock (Reboot) demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9d57e
Well that's a word. I can't say I disagree, I'm just a bit more happy/excited to see a playable SS1 remake than you are apparently. Fair enough.

665b1f8d9d7a7voodoo47

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9d807
no public release at this point, or did I miss something?
Re: The System Shock (Reboot) demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9d8fe
Not a failed remake either. Here's to hope and chaos.
Re: The System Shock (Reboot) demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9dbd9
Quote by Thiefsiefool:
I'm really not feeling the tiny interaction objects.

I like the fine interactivity when using small objects. General use of doors could get annoying because there's so many though, but I'm fine with the current setup for keypads, puzzles and medbays.

665b1f8d9de23Schuler

Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9de7b
no public release at this point, or did I miss something?

I posted it to explain why JJ "ouch"'d.

665b1f8d9e169Schuler

Re: The System Shock (Reboot) demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9e1be
Well that's a word. I can't say I disagree, I'm just a bit more happy/excited to see a playable SS1 remake than you are apparently. Fair enough.

Hey this was a million-to-one shot so I'm amazed (see me giving a point just for existing) but bad modern sequels have come out before (Invisible War). I can be glad something's here, and point out how it can get better at the same time.
Re: The System Shock remake demo is OUT!
665b1f8d9e607
no public release at this point, or did I miss something?
Well, you could download the git and play whatever is ready so far.
1 Guest is here.
They are never just monkeys
Contact SMF 2.0.19 | SMF © 2016, Simple Machines | Terms and Policies
FEEP
665b1f8da1a3a